[ Cell Phones & Plans ] Open Question : I need help deciding between 2 phones. Can anyone give me any advice as to which one is better?

I am looking for a new phone (I am on verizon and I do not want to pay the data package). I currently have the voyager, but both screens are cracked (due to skateboarding). I text a lot so the voyager has helped with that but i need a new phone. I have a choice of getting the voyager again or getting the Samsung Convoy. I am usually kind of rough on my phones so the Convoy would be a good choice. But i really like the keyboard for texting. I am leaning more towards the voyager again but can anyone give me any advice onto which might be the better phone?